DONATE TO HAND TODAY!
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
  • Rss

Housing Association of Nonprofit Developers (HAND)

  • ABOUT
    • MEET THE TEAM
    • BOARD OF DIRECTORS
    • ANNUAL REPORT
  • MEMBERS
    • JOIN OR RENEW MEMBERSHIP
    • MEMBER BENEFITS
    • MEMBERS-ONLY PORTAL
    • MEMBER DIRECTORY
    • CAREER CENTER
    • INDUSTRY RFPS
  • PROGRAMS
    • 2022-2023 TRAINING & CAPACITY BUILDING SERIES
    • ANNUAL HAND HONORS
    • GENERATIONHAND
      • GENERATIONHAND SCHOLARSHIP
  • POLICY ACTIVATIONS
    • HOUSING INDICATOR TOOL
    • EQUITY IN ACTION
    • MY RIGHT, MY FIGHT
  • EQUITY
    • DESIGN TEAM
    • RESOURCE CENTER
    • LEARNING SERIES
    • RE FAST FIVE
    • WHEN WE ALL VOTE
  • RESOURCES
    • BLOG
      • AREAS OF NEED
      • MEMBER EVENTS & SUCCESS STORIES
      • OPPORTUNITIES
    • SUBSCRIBE
  • SUPPORTERS

Blog - Latest News

Should We Put a Dollar Value on the Benefits of Affordable Housing?

January 21, 2016
January 21, 2016

family on floor

We are all aware that having access to affordable, quality housing in a safe neighborhood that is connected to jobs and other amenities makes life better for people.  Research has shown the positive relationship between stable, affordable housing and good health outcomes, improved academic performance and greater economic self-sufficiency. Individuals and families with low-incomes who have access to housing that is affordable undoubtedly benefit from that housing.  For some, that is reason enough to support public spending on affordable housing programs. But what about others who ask about the return on investment in affordable housing? To what extent should we make the economic case for affordable housing?

Putting a dollar value on the benefits associated with access to affordable housing is a tricky business.  Housing researchers have tended to avoid monetizing benefits—and for good reasons. It can be really difficult to establish definitively that receipt of housing assistance causes a change in an individual’s or family’s condition.  Even if that link could be shown, the benefits might be a long time coming and it can be hard to track people and measure changes over years or even decades.  Some housing advocates also balk at putting a dollar value on the benefits of housing, arguing that housing is a right and economic benefits need not be part of the discussion.house balance

There is a little research, however, that has put a dollar value on the benefits of affordable housing. Monetizing the health benefits associated with housing is probably the most common way return on investment has been measured.  In a review of the research on the intersection of housing and health, Janet Viveiros and I found a number of rigorous studies that have demonstrated that providing permanent supportive housing to homeless individuals saves money on public health care expenditures. In fact, it can be far more cost effective to provide housing to homeless individuals than to provide the extra health care and other services they need when they are not stably housed.

Aside from the permanent supportive housing research, there is little analysis on the public benefits of other affordable housing programs.  One exception is recent research by Raj Chetty and his collaborators at Harvard. They analyzed data from the Moving to Opportunity (MTO) housing voucher program and found that children in families that had access to a voucher under this program had higher incomes later in life.  And, over the long term, the additional tax revenue collected on these increased earnings were more than enough to offset the cost of the voucher program. So, investing in this housing voucher program had a positive return—albeit, many years after the fact.

workersHow does investing in affordable housing relate to regional economic growth? Although I’ve made the claim in the past that a lack of affordable housing can lead to slower economic growth, there hasn’t been any systematic research that definitely confirms that hypothesis.  There is, however, new and compelling research that hints at the important role housing plays in regional prosperity.  Researchers Chris Benner and Manuel Pastor examined economic growth in metro areas across the U.S. and found that places with higher inequality and more segregation have slower job growth and less sustainable economic development. By extension, local and regional housing policies that lead to less inequality and more residential integration should lead to stronger regional economies. And theoretically one could monetize the value to the regional economy of pursuing those types of inclusive housing policies.

So, there is a lot of potential for quantifying the broad economic benefits of affordable housing programs and policies.  But for now, researchers have tended not to focus on measuring the return on investment of public spending on housing. It seems like we could do a better job on this. Even as we realize that a “cost-benefit” or “return-on-investment” analysis should not be the sole driver of housing policy decisions, it can be a useful part of the discussion.  And it can help make the case for affordable housing programs to those who take a “bottom line” approach to government spending decisions.

1 Comment/in HAND News, HAND Thought Leadership /by H.A.N.D.
1 reply
  1. Ralph Bennett says:
    February 23, 2016 at 11:21 am

    Good ideas, diplomatically stated. Short term ROI infects our investment strategies, starting with the stock market. We defer infrastructure maintenance to our heirs as it collapses, yielding broadly participatory economic leadership to others. Progressive housing policy plans for the long term. Income integrated housing works – it provides social cohesion through personal contact, reducing the costs of all kinds of segregation, and providing complete workforces near the job sites. Rewarding such housing by underwriting long term ROI over short term gain could be a big help.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest from Facebook

This message is only visible to admins.
Problem displaying Facebook posts. Backup cache in use.
Click to show error
Error: Error validating access token: The session has been invalidated because the user changed their password or Facebook has changed the session for security reasons. Type: OAuthException

Annual Meeting Important Information

Payments: Orders placed on the event registration page are not confirmed until payment is received. A confirmation email will be sent to the email address listed in your registration. If you paid by credit card, a receipt will be sent to the email address listed in your registration. If you mail a check, all payments must be received within seven days of completing your registration form. Checks should be remitted to: HAND, PO Box 48386, Washington, DC 20002

Guest List & Dietary Preference: If your registration includes a luncheon table or multiple guests, please submit guest names and menu choices by May 1, 2020. Submit guest names here.

Housing Expo: Plan to exhibit? Download the Housing Expo FAQs here.

Omni Shoreham Hotel Room Block: For attendees looking to secure overnight accommodations on May 25th, HAND has secured a rate starting at $189 for conference attendees. There are a limited amount of rooms available, so visit this link today to reserve your room. May 10th is the last day to secure a room at the discounted rate.

 Ad Submission: The artwork for advertisements should be submitted to annualmeeting@handhousing.org. You can download the ad spec sheet here. Deadline for ad submission is April 13, 2020.

Cancellations & Changes: If you wish to cancel or change your registration for the Annual Meeting & Housing Expo, please send a request in writing to annualmeeting@handhousing.org. All cancellation requests made prior to April 27th will receive a 50% refund. For cancellation requests made after April 27th, no refund will be provided.

Door Prizes: Are you interested in donating a door prize to this year’s Annual Meeting? Email annualmeeting@handhousing.org to coordinate with our team.

← HAND Member Spotlight: Emerging Leader Catherine Inniss, Baltimore Renaissance Group (previous entry)
(next entry) Governor McAuliffe Awards APAH $750K for Columbia Hills Apartments →

Latest News

  • Five Minutes With David Bowers & Paul StanfordDecember 7, 2022 - 5:36 pm
  • Five Minutes With John HallNovember 21, 2022 - 7:21 pm
  • Help Arlington County Track How Their Broadband Stacks Up!September 21, 2022 - 1:28 pm
  • What the Inflation Reduction Act Could Mean for DC Residents and BusinessesSeptember 21, 2022 - 12:20 pm

New Members

  • Fernando Miranda Jr.March 22, 2023 - 3:12 pm
  • Regions Affordable HousingFebruary 10, 2023 - 11:45 am
  • Compass Inc.January 23, 2023 - 11:38 am
  • New World DevelopersAugust 17, 2022 - 3:41 pm
  • BHI- Construction and Real Estate DevelopmentAugust 17, 2022 - 3:39 pm
  • Paragon Construction Group, Inc.August 17, 2022 - 3:38 pm

Contact Information

Mailing Address:
HAND
P.O. Box 48386
Washington, DC 20002

info@handhousing.org

202.384.3764
Staff Directory

MEDIA INQUIRIES?
communications@handhousing.org

INTERESTED IN HAND UPDATES?
Sign up for the distribution list here.

© Copyright Housing Association of Nonprofit Developers (HAND)